SOA: Checking postconditions is more important than checking preconditions

1 minute read

I see quite a few models for Service Oriented Architectures that employ pipelines with validating "gatekeeper" stages that verify whether inbound messages are valid according to an agreed contract. Validation on inbound messages is a reactive action resulting from distrust of the communication partner's ability to adhere to the contract. Validation on inbound messages shields a service from invalid input data, but seen from the perspective of the entire system, the action occurs too late.

What I see less often is a gatekeeper on outbound channels that verifies whether the currently executing local service adheres to the agreed communication contract. Validation on outbound messages is a proactive action taken in order to create trust with partners about the local service's ability to adhere to a contract. Furthermore, validation on outbound messages is quite often the last chance action before a well-known point of no return: the transaction boundary. If a service is faulty, for whatever reason, it needs to consistently fail and abort transactions instead of emitting incorrect messages that are in violation of the contract. If the service is faulty, it must consequently be assumed that compensating recovery strategies will not function properly and with the desired result.

Exception information that is generated on an inbound channel, especially in asynchronous one-way scenarios, vanishes into a log file at a location/organization that may not even own the sending service that's in violation of the contract. The only logical place to detect contract violations in order to isolate and efficiently eliminate problems is on the outbound, not on the inbound channel. Eliminating problems may mean to fix problems in the software, allow manual correction by an operator/clerk or an automatic rejection/rollback/retry of the operation yielding the incorrect result. None of these corrective actions can be done in a meaningful way by the message recipient. The recipient can shield itself, and that is and remains very important. However, it's just a desperate act of digging oneself in when the last line of defense did already fall.


Leave a Comment